Setting Spray vs Setting Powder: Which Should You Use?

Setting Spray vs Setting Powder: Which Should You Use?

There are so many beauty products on the market all promising to be the magic solution to your makeup needs. Setting Spray vs Setting Powder, which should you use??? Keep scrolling to learn the pros and cons of both to see what the better product is for you!

What is Setting Spray

Setting spray is basically hairspray for your face! Just like you use hairspray to hold your hairstyle, setting spray holds your makeup all day. You can learn more about what setting spray is and how to use it.

What is Setting Powder

Setting powder is meant to help your makeup stay all day, plus keep your face looking matte and less shiny. You can read more about what setting powder is and how to apply it.

Pros of Setting Spray

As with all beauty products, there are some pros and cons! Here are some pros of setting spray:

  • Setting spray helps your makeup last all day.
  • Setting spray can be used as a primer and as a setting spray!
  • Setting spray can help your eyeshadow apply more pigmented.
  • Setting spray can give you a dewy glow.

Pros of Setting Powder

Here are some pros of setting powder:

  • If you have oily skin, it will help absorb the excess oil, giving you a less shiny appearance.
  • If you want a matte look, setting powder will keep the shine at bay.
  • Setting powder helps your makeup stay put.

Cons of Setting Spray

There are some common mistakes with setting spray that end up making the user experience less than desirable. Here are some cons of setting spray:

  • If you have oily skin, setting spray can make you look a little shiny.
  • Some setting sprays conflict with the ingredients in makeup. Choose one that works well with the makeup you wear.
  • If you touch your face, your makeup can still come off.
  • Setting spray can sting your eyes if applied incorrectly.

Cons of Setting Powder

There are also common mistakes with setting powder that can make the process and outcome frustrating. Here are some cons of setting powder:

  • Most setting powders have talc, which can be bad for your health. (the Airspun talc-free version is a great option though!)
  • Powder can be messy. (a mess-free way to apply powder is with this Powder Brush)
  • If you apply too much, it can crease and add texture to your makeup.

When Should You Use Setting Spray

Setting spray is great at helping your makeup last all day but it’s not necessary for everyone to use. If you have dry to normal skin and you want your makeup to last longer, setting spray will be a great addition to your makeup routine. If you are noticing that your makeup is disappearing or coming off mid-day, then setting spray can help it last longer.

If you have oily skin, some setting sprays can make your face look shiny. The NYX Matte Finish Setting Spray is a good option for oily skin.

When Should You Use Setting Powder

Just like setting spray isn’t for everyone, setting powder isn’t for everyone either! If you have normal to oily skin and you want a more matte look and a less shiny appearance, setting powder will be your best friend!

Setting powder will help absorb your excess oil and give you a more matte finish. There are several ways to apply setting powder, depending on your needs and preferences.

Best Setting Spray

Not all setting sprays are created equal! Here are 6 tried and true setting sprays that work great and consist of a range of prices:

Seint Stay Setting Spray

NYX Matte Finish

Coola Setting Spray

Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray

Hydro Grip Setting Spray

All Nighter Setting Spray

The Best Setting Sprays for Seint Makeup

Best Setting Powder

Not all powders are created equal! There are some powders that work best with cream makeup and there are some powders that are just a better quality than others. Here are 4 tried and true setting powders that work great:

Seint Vanilla Dust Setting Powder

Coty Airspun Loose Setting Powder

Laura Mercier Translucent Powder

Makeup Forever Loose Powder

The Best Powders for Seint Makeup


So….setting spray vs setting powder, which should you use? It depends on your skin and your preference! If you have dry skin, stick to setting spray. If you have oily skin, stick to setting powder. If you have normal skin, you choose! Makeup is a bit of trial and error. Play around with products and see what you like and what you don’t like. Have fun with it!

Color Match Me!
Shop Here!

Here are other blogposts you might enjoy:

How to Color Match Yourself with Seint Makeup

How to Look Younger with Makeup for Women over 40

5 Minute Makeup for Women Over 40

Contour Tips and Tricks

Eyeshadow Tips for Hooded Eyes

Setting Spray vs Setting Powder: Which Should You Use?

About the Author

JoEllen is a licensed aesthetician, makeup mentor, and certified John Maxwell coach, speaker, and trainer. She has been working with women for 18 years helping them look and feel confident. She loves teaching women simple beauty techniques so they can feel empowered to try it at home. She believes that when you look and feel good, you do good!

*This post contains affiliate links. If you choose to purchase an item featured in this post, I get a small portion from the sale. Thank you! It does not affect you at all.